Best practices for setting goals and measuring success with remote workers

Setting goals for your employees is an essential part of managing a team. However, goals alone are not enough, you also need to regularly evaluate their progress toward those goals. Employee evaluations help you and your team understand what's working and what needs to change going forward.

When you manage remote workers—a group that included 35.5 million people in the U.S. as of early 2024—it's even more important to measure their progress and success. In-person meetings are powerful, but your remote evaluations can have the same impact when done correctly. This guide walks you through proven strategies for setting clear goals, measuring success effectively, and building accountability without micromanaging your distributed team.

Why Goal Setting Matters More for Remote Teams

When your team is spread across cities and time zones, you can't rely on office osmosis to keep everyone aligned. Clear, documented goals become the connective tissue that holds your remote team together—they transform abstract company objectives into concrete, individual missions.

Here's the thing: remote workers need goals to thrive. Without casual office visibility, well-structured goals become your primary tool for maintaining alignment and demonstrating impact.

Common Challenges in Remote Goal Setting

Setting goals for a remote team isn't the same as for an in-office one. You're likely facing a unique set of hurdles that sound familiar: you want to trust your team, but you also need to ensure work is getting done.

The most common remote goal-setting challenges include:

• Visibility gaps: Lack of insight into daily progress without office presence
• Fairness concerns: Difficulty maintaining consistent standards across locations
• Communication barriers: Missing spontaneous check-ins that surface roadblocks
• Time zone conflicts: Synchronous collaboration feels impossible
• Cultural misalignment: Different expectations about communication and work patterns

Evaluating Remote Employees: The Basics

Employee evaluations, at their core, should be about maintaining a productive dialogue with your team members. Navigating these conversations with remote employees can be challenging, but investing the time to do it right will pay off.

When you're evaluating remote employees, try applying these tips below to make the process more streamlined.

1. Establish clear expectations

The topics and findings discussed with your remote employees during their evaluations shouldn't be surprising to them. To keep everyone on the same page, establish clear and realistic expectations for your employees. Let them know how often you plan to evaluate their performance, what topics will be discussed in performance reviews, and what your priorities for them are.

Expectations for remote workers may differ from those for in-person employees, so be sure your remote team understands what is expected of them. This information will provide the groundwork for successful employee evaluations down the line.

2. Set measurable goals

Vague goals aren't useful to you or your employees. Instead of setting abstract goals for your remote workers, make sure they have measurable benchmarks. Since remote workers likely complete most of their work online, you should have access to data that can be used to quantitatively measure their progress.

With a remote sales representative, for example, your goal may be for the employee to reach more conversions. You would set a benchmark of how many conversions you want them to complete. That way, your employee would have a clear goal to work toward and could measure their own progress toward that number.

3. Schedule biweekly check-ins

Traditionally, managers evaluated employees annually, but that schedule doesn't fit with the modern work environment, where the share of fully remote teleworkers has decreased by 6.1 percentage points in just one year. Keeping an open dialogue with team members and regularly checking in with them is the better approach to employee evaluations. Since remote employees can't just drop by your office with questions or concerns, frequent check-ins are even more important.

Bi-weekly check-ins with remote employees hit the perfect middle ground between too much and not enough communication. These meetings are frequent enough to give you a good idea of their progress without being so overbearing.

For the most productive communication, avoid check-ins by email. Though convenient, email is less effective for evaluation discussions with remote workers than video or phone calls.

4. Tie daily tasks to long-term goals

Setting quantifiable goals will help guide remote employees toward success. However, they may still struggle to understand how their daily tasks relate to the long-term goals you set together. Tying those big-picture goals to concrete daily tasks can help ensure that remote employees make progress every day.

Your remote employees will be more motivated to complete their daily work if they understand how finishing those tasks gets them closer to their goals. Making the connection between long-term goals and daily tasks can also eliminate the urge to micromanage your remote workers, freeing you up to focus on other work.

5. Identify available resources for support

It's common for remote workers to feel isolated. In your discussions with remote employees, make sure to identify resources they can use if they need help achieving their goals. Applicable resources include online training, mentorship meetings, and productivity tools.

💡 Check out this webinar on evaluating global talent with expert insights from Oyster, Chili Piper, Niya, and Jobs for Humanity.

Types of Goals That Work Best for Remote Workers

So, what makes a remote goal actually effective? For the large portion of remote workers in management, professional, and related occupations, the best goals focus on outcomes, not activity. Focus on setting goals that are:

• Outcome-based: Instead of "Make 20 calls a day," try "Book 5 qualified demos per week."
• Project-based: Define clear deliverables and deadlines for specific projects.
• Quantifiable: Use frameworks like SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, Time-bound) goals to eliminate ambiguity.

Remember, remote workers thrive when they understand not just what to do, but why it matters. Connect every goal to broader team or company objectives to maintain motivation and alignment.

How to Measure Remote Worker Success

Once you've established open communication around goals, how do you actually measure success? Here's your step-by-step approach:

• Compare results to benchmarks: Review actual outcomes against the quantifiable goals you set
• Discuss variances: Talk through any significant differences with your team members
• Gather peer feedback: Ask for team insights—remote workers often have valuable perspectives on each other's contributions
• Review and adjust: Goals should evolve as roles grow and company priorities shift

Tools and Systems for Remote Goal Tracking

Here's the reality: the right tool supports your process—it doesn't replace it. While spreadsheets work for small teams, growing distributed companies need dedicated systems.

Look for tools that reduce manual check-ins:

• Project management: Asana, Trello, or Monday.com
• Communication: Slack or Microsoft Teams
• Global employment platforms: Unified team management across borders

The goal is creating a single source of truth for progress. Prioritize tools that integrate with your existing workflows without requiring constant status updates.

Creating Accountability Without Micromanaging

Accountability in a remote team is built on trust and clarity. It starts with making sure everyone knows what success looks like and feels empowered to get there.

Shift your focus from monitoring activity to discussing progress. Use your regular check-ins to ask supportive questions like:

• "What roadblocks are you facing?"
• "What do you need from me to achieve this goal?"
• "How can I better support your success?"

This approach fosters ownership and turns performance conversations into productive partnerships.

Completing effective employee evaluations is just one of the challenges of managing a global team, but the right tools can make things easier. Oyster's global employment platform helps you grow and manage a remote team across borders.

With the right global employment partner, you can manage your entire team's lifecycle in one place, from compliant offers to onboarding, payroll, and benefits. When you can trust that the operational details are handled, you have more time to focus on what matters most: supporting your team and helping them achieve their goals. Start hiring globally with Oyster.

Frequently Asked Questions About Remote Goal Setting

How often should I adjust goals for remote workers?

Review goals formally each quarter, with progress discussions in biweekly check-ins. This cadence provides agility without disruptive constant changes.

How do I handle goal setting across different time zones?

Use asynchronous communication and shared documents for goal updates. Reserve synchronous meetings for strategic discussions, not status reports.

What should I do when remote workers aren't meeting their goals?

Approach with curiosity, not accusation—understand the "why" first. Use it as a coaching opportunity to create a supportive plan together.